Let’s talk about one of the most misunderstood tools in the nutrition world: macros.
In most carnivore spaces, macros rarely come up — and when they do, it’s usually followed by someone saying, “You don’t need to track anything. Just eat meat until you’re full.”
It’s true that when you’re eating minimally processed, whole foods — like meat, eggs, and butter — you’re not dealing with the same dopamine traps or engineered hyper-palatability that come with processed foods. Your hunger cues should naturally balance out.
But if you’ve ever used food of any kind as emotional support, “eating until you’re full” isn’t that simple — because you were never eating just to feel full in the first place.
For me, macros aren’t about restriction. They’re a tool that gives me a little structure and guidance — and that structure leads to awareness. When my macros start creeping up for the day, it’s my cue to check in with myself. Am I actually hungry, or am I just bored? Sometimes I realize I’m not hungry at all — I just need to move my body, go for a walk, spend time with my kids, or talk with my husband. Those little moments of connection remind me that food doesn’t have to be the answer every time something feels off.
The goal for me is to become an expert in what works for me. To arm myself with the knowledge so that I can make intentional, educated decisions and always have a fallback map in my back pocket.
When I first started, I lost 45 pounds doing equal parts protein and fat. Then I hit a stall and had to switch things up. Sometimes I’ll lift my protein and lower my fat; other times I’ll flip it — or as Missy Elliott says, “flip it and reverse it.” There’s no perfect formula, because our bodies are always changing. What worked six months ago might not work now — and that’s okay.
At the end of the day, it comes down to this: if it works for you, awesome. If counting macros helps you realign with your goals — like it does for me — use it. But if it stresses you out, makes you obsessive, or causes more harm than good, skip it. And if you’re one of those rare aliens who can eat until your body is perfectly nourished and never take a bite more — you definitely don’t need to count macros.
Put aside the diet labels and the rules. Experiment for yourself. Use the data as feedback, not judgment, and find what actually works for you.
Do You Really Need to Count Macros on Carnivore?

I love what you said about being an expert in what works for ourselves – I’ve tried to copy other folks macros or eating until full and I end up sick or in trouble. This continues to be a work in progress, seeing where I am comfortable in this woe.
Hi Harriet!
So glad this resonated with you! 💛 You’re absolutely right — health and wellness aren’t linear. It’s such a spiral journey of learning, unlearning, and finding what feels best for you. What works now may evolve down the road, and that’s completely normal. It’s all about experimenting, exploring, and meeting yourself with patience and self-compassion along the way.
I LOVE your way of thinking about things. Hey, I judge myself enough, I don’t need everyone else doing it also. Thanks for being the voice of reason. Have a wonderful day!!
Love hearing that, truly. ❤️ I hope it helps you feel a little lighter today. Give yourself some grace, no extra judgment needed! Sending lots of love on your health and wellness journey.